contents
Imagine Your Health®
 
We value your opinion. Please use the contact link in the bottom right corner of our site to provide your feedback. Thanks.

He said, She said
Nina and Mick come to blows when we ask who should pay the tab print article     
send to a friend

He says. "You gals have to pay half of the tab."
By Mick Richards

I once spent a meal being berated by a cute feminist on why I was such a jerk for being a man and not a woman. And when the check came, I reached for it - she didn't move. She didn't offer to pay half, and didn't even pretend to. This had been a spur-of-the-moment dinner date, and was her idea. She had even chosen the rather pricey sushi joint herself. Later, when she had a chance to compensate for the dinner debt by springing for a movie, she didn't. I paid for the movie and was rewarded by being screamed at for opening the door to the theater for her. "That's the kind of male chauvinism I was talking about, Mick."

This kind of stuff is confusing to a guy. Why is it that 99 percent of the time, you want to be treated and respected as equals, yet when it comes to paying for dinner, you turn into June Cleaver? The bottom line is that you gals have to pay half of the tab. If you want equal rights, equal pay, equal time in the bedroom, and equal everything else, then you have to pay for half of dinner as well. Period. You can't have it both ways.

Chivalry Lives

I do believe in chivalry. I think guys should hold the door open for women because doors are heavy, and let's face it, all women really need us for is lifting heavy things. I pull my date's chair out for her at dinner because women seem to enjoy it and I'll do damn near anything that may improve my chances. I've never laid my coat over a puddle so that a woman could walk over it because I live in Southern California, and there just aren't many puddles. I do hold umbrellas, offer coats in the cold, and generally treat the women I care about like queens because I love them. But always paying for dinner is where I draw the line.

My point of view may be skewed somewhat by the fact that the majority of women I date make more money than me. These days it is not uncommon for a fully employed, independent, financially secure woman to expect her deadbeat writer boyfriend to pay for things like meals, cabs, and bar tabs. It defies all logic. Ridiculous disparities in earnings should negate any sex-based approach to check splitting.

 

She Says. "Treat a lady to a night out every once in a while!"
By Nina Gallagher

Chivalry - The qualities idealized by knighthood, such as bravery, courtesy, honor, and gallantry toward women.
*Source: The American HeritageŽ Dictionary of the English Language, Third Edition

If chivalry is dead then I'm joining a primitive tribe, where money isn't an issue and dining out means, literally, dining out, and there's no stuffy waiter agonizing over whom to present the check to at the conclusion of the meal.

What happened to our old concept of a date? A man finds a woman attractive, he asks her out, she says yes, he takes her to dinner and maybe a movie, and to show her that he knows how to take care of others, he pays the tab. In the good old days, it was called chivalry; a knight in shining armor rescued the damsel in distress from the fire-breathing dragon.

While most women would like to avoid the stereotypes that were forced upon them in those times, there are aspects of the life that can be carried to the present day. Many women still appreciate being taken care every once in a while (doesn't everyone?). While asserting our independence, it's comforting to know that there is someone to lean on. Let's face it ladies, it's a turn-on to know that there is a big, strong man waiting to take care of us. And it's not like we don't take care of them. I haven't met a man yet that likes to do laundry or sew a button back on to a shirt.

Regardless of advances in feminism, many men and women still believe that a man should be a provider. I'm not asking for you to believe that men should be the sole breadwinners, just that they treat a lady to a night out every once in awhile. The caveman went out hunting and brought home the bacon. In modern times, a man should use his typically larger income to spring for sushi. Let's not kid ourselves; even though women have moved into the workplace, men still make more money. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, on average men made almost $20,000 more than women in 1999!

If the situation were reversed, I wouldn't mind picking up the tab.

Do you have an opinion on this subject? Click here to e-mail Nina and Mick! Selected letters will be published.